Welcome to a straightforward bison sirloin steak recipe. If you're a fan of bison steak and enjoy the tenderness reminiscent of filet mignon, this one's for you. The best part? Cooking bison sirloin is as easy as preparing a filet. In this recipe, we'll guide you through the uncomplicated steps to ensure a delicious result.
Pan Seared Bison Sirloin Steak
Pan Seared Bison Sirloin Steak
Rated 3.2 stars by 13 users
Category
Buffalo
Cuisine
American
Author:
Sarah Knight
Servings
2
Prep Time
45 minutes
Cook Time
15-20 minutes
Whether you're a seasoned buffalo enthusiast or trying it for the first time, this recipe showcases the simplicity and versatility of bison meat. Get ready for a no-fuss cooking experience that brings out the best in bison sirloin steak. Let's dive into the straightforward preparation of this delectable dish.

Ingredients
-
Bison Sirloin
-
1 stick of butter
-
salt to taste
- 1 clove of garlic
Directions
Open your bison sirloin package 45 minutes before cooking. Pat dry and place on a paper towel-lined plate. Salt generously on both sides. Allow the meat to come to room temperature.
While the sirloin comes up in temperature make some garlic pan butter for the basting. Cut a clove of garlic in half, and open side down let the garlic cook in the butter.
Use medium heat. If it’s too high, your garlic will burn, leaving a burnt, bitter flavor in your butter. Once finished, strain your garlic and leave the butter in the pan.
- Set your burner to medium-high, and once the butter starts bubbling again, pat your sirloin dry again as the salt will bring moisture to the surface.
Place in the pan on one side, and leave it there. Do not flip it until a nice caramel brown has appeared. Do not press it either, this doesn’t speed up the process in a beneficial way, it just creates a flat steak.
Once flipped, tilt your pan towards you so the butter pools and you can start to baste with a spoon. You may need to add more butter at this point if it has darkened too much.
- Keep basting until the underside of your sirloin has the same caramel brown. Once this happens, flip it once more, baste the other side for a minute, then turn off your burner.
- Leave the sirloin steak in the pan for sixty seconds, then remove it to your cutting board and let rest for five minutes.
- You should have a perfectly medium rare steak.