Standard hot dogs and grocery store beef patties have their place, but they do not necessarily make a memorable weekend. If you are hosting an outdoor BBQ and want to truly impress your guests, the solution is shifting the menu to premium, native game meat.
Cooking premium game meat like bison, elk, and wild boar on an open flame elevates a casual backyard cookout into a high-end culinary experience. Because these pasture-raised meats are naturally lean and intensely flavorful, many backyard cooks worry about ruining an expensive cut. Grilling game meat does not require a culinary degree. It just requires a few basic shifts in your strategy. This guide breaks down the best meats for a summer BBQ and pairs them with foolproof recipes to guarantee success.
Why Game Meat is the Ultimate Summer BBQ Showstopper
The best meats for grilling should carry deep, clean flavor without relying on heavy pools of sugary barbecue sauce. Wild game delivers a richer profile than standard beef or pork while offering a much cleaner nutritional profile. Use this quick reference guide to understand your cuts before you light the fire.
|
Premium Cut |
Flavor Profile |
Leaner Than Beef/Pork? |
Ideal Grilling Temp |
Quick Pitmaster Rule |
|
Bison Steak |
Rich, slightly sweet, clean |
Yes (85% leaner) |
130°F–135°F (Medium-Rare) |
Cooks roughly 30% faster than beef; pull it off the heat 5-10 degrees below your target temp. |
|
Elk Tenderloin |
Mild, savory, zero gamey taste |
Yes |
125-130°F (Rare to Med-Rare) |
Use a two-zone fire to sear hot, then move to indirect heat to finish. |
|
Wild Boar Chops |
Nutty, rich, deeply flavorful |
Yes |
145-150°F (Medium) |
Pairs perfectly with sweet fruit-based or bourbon glazes but don’t add until the final few minutes to avoid burning. |
Bison Meat: The High-End Steakhouse Experience
If you want the texture of a premium steakhouse cut but with a rich, slightly sweet flavor profile, bison meat is the undisputed gold standard for premium BBQ meats.
Thick Cuts: Tomahawk & T-Bone
For a dramatic presentation that stops guests in their tracks, you cannot beat thick, bone-in bison steak. Follow our guide to cooking a Reverse Seared Dry Aged Bison Tomahawk Steak for perfect results, or master the flame with our recipe for Grilled Bison T-Bone Steak with Caramelized Onions.
Sliced Platters for a Crowd: Tri-Tip & Skirt Steak
Feeding a large group does not mean you have to cook individual steaks. Large cuts can be grilled whole, sliced thin, and served on large platters. Check out our Reverse-Seared Bison Tri-Tip with Summer Salad and Pesto, explore the classic Santa Maria Style Tri-Tip, or throw down a fast-cooking crowd favorite with our Charcoal-Grilled Bison Skirt Steak with Spring Chimichurri.
The Ultimate Bison Burgers
If you are going to serve burgers, make them unforgettable. Trading standard ground beef for ground bison elevates the backyard staple into something extraordinary. Get our step-by-step masterclass on Grilled Buffalo Burgers to keep them juicy every single time.
Elk Meat: Rich, Lean, and Elegantly Tender
When comparing the best cuts of beef to grill against elk meat, elk wins on tenderness and flavor every time. It is incredibly fine-grained, meaning it melts in your mouth when prepared correctly.
Premium Elk Steaks and Skewers
Elk tenderloin is one of the most prized cuts of premium game meat. Keep it simple and elegant by preparing a Marinated and Grilled Elk Tenderloin, or indulge your guests with an American Elk Tenderloin with Whiskey Butter. For an interactive, finger-food option that works perfectly for mingling crowds, try these Elk Ribeye Yakitori Skewers.
Casual Cookout Upgrades: Beer Can Burgers & Brats
You can still keep things casual while upgrading the quality of the protein. Try our impressive Elk Meat Beer Can Burgers or load up the grill grate with snap-case Grilled Elk Bratwurst Sausages.
Wild Boar: The Unforgettable Alternative to Pork
Wild boar is not ordinary pork. Because these animals forage on native nuts, seeds, and plants, wild boar carries a distinctively rich, nutty flavor profile that makes the taste and appearance of standard store bought pork fall flat.
Grilled Boar Chops and Glazed Tenderloins
The natural flavor of wild boar pairs beautifully with sweet, smoky, and acidic elements. Elevate your next cookout with a decadent Grilled Bacon Wrapped Boar Tenderloin with Brown Sugar Bourbon Glaze. For a street-food style gathering, build a menu around Grilled Wild Boar Tenderloin Tacos al Pastor, or stick to the classics with our Marinated Grilled Wild Boar Chops.
Grilling Tips from the Pitmaster: Don’t Ruin Your Premium Cuts
Because game meat lacks the heavy, insulating pockets of white marbling fat found in commercial beef, it is sensitive to overcooking. Treat these premium cuts with the respect they deserve by following two non-negotiable rules.
Rule #1: The Two-Zone Fire Setup
Never cook lean game steaks over direct, blinding heat from start to finish. You will char the outside to a crisp before the interior even warms up. Master our Two-Zone Fire setup to create a hot searing zone and a cooler, indirect roasting zone. This gives you complete control over the cook.
Rule #2: The Power of a Good Game Meat Marinade
A great marinade serves two purposes for wild game: it introduces complimentary acidity to tenderize the lean muscle fibers, and it binds surface moisture to create an incredible crust. Prepare your cuts using our proven Grilled Elk Steak Marinade Recipe or add a bold, rich punch to your dinner with this Whiskey Brown Sugar Elk Steak Marinade.
Secure Your Summer Lineup
A great summer gathering requires great preparation. Do not settle for grocery store compromises when you can serve authentic, premium game meats sourced directly from the American West. Head over to the Jackson Hole Buffalo Meat Co. grilling collections to secure your premium steaks, burgers, and sausages before your next major weekend gathering.
[Browse Our Summer Grill Favorites]
Frequently Asked Questions About Grilling Wild Game
How do you keep wild game meat from drying out on the grill?
Because game meat is exceptionally lean, the secret is controlling your temperature and cooking time. Use a digital meat thermometer, cook over a two-zone fire, and always pull the meat off the grill 5 degrees before it reaches your target internal temperature. The meat will continue to cook as it rests.
Can you eat bison and elk steaks rare?
Yes. High-quality bison and elk steaks are best enjoyed rare to medium-rare. Cooking them past medium destroys the delicate texture and dries out the meat because there is no heavy fat marbling to protect it at higher temperatures.
How much meat should I buy per guest for a BBQ?
As a general rule of thumb, plan for 1/2 pound (8 ounces) of bone-out meat per adult guest, or 3/4 pound (12 ounces) for bone-in cuts like Tomahawks or T-Bones. If you are serving hearty sides or a multi-course menu, you can safely scale back slightly.
